- Messages
- 2,177
- Reaction score
- 273
- Trophy Points
- 113
Moe_Syzlak said:History repeating itself as a theme is fine and dandy. But it has to be executed well. This wasn't IMO. Making everything EXACTLY the same made the history repeating feel reductive and lazy and fan service. I might have felt differently if Rey was on some planet other than a desert planet, etc. To have that theme work it has to feel like a its recurring not completely repeating. But it was stilll way better than than the PT.
Personally I agree with Moe, though given that I'm ok with Phantom Menace and Revenge of the Sith and am 50/50 with Attack of the Clones, I disagree with the last sentence but only story and character wise. Technically Force Awakens is better but story and charcter wise, which is what I find most important in a film, I prefer the Prequels, even though their tone is awkward & all over the place and the writing, dialogue and execution is quite poor. Force Awakens is the opposite to me. Much better technically and in writing, dialogue and execution but story and character wise quite poor, at least in my opinion.