- Reaction score
- Trophy Points
I didn't catch the blead through on the "HEY" until you pointed it out... Great catch! After I knew what I was looking for, I heard it loud and clear! So that is now corrected. I also adjusted the fades and made them blend better. I also took your advice on using a visual cue for the music change and it is now when they realize the door is jammed. Let me know if this seems better when I upload the new clip please. These are the things that are easy for me to over look and why I need your guys help...
Awesome, that all sounds like you got a handle on it, great to hear.
I am going to respectfully disagree with you here. The reason is that the last shot of the guys running in the hall are towards the camera and you know they are going past that point. So the door can easily be placed behind the camera.
I understand, that's reasonable, and this one was super "opinion-y".
The R2 and 3PO footage started with a shake but stops before we get the the R1 footage, and It doesn't look to me like there is any camera shake on the R1 footage either? I noticed the alarm sound is gone when we cut to this footage, but the alarm sound was never in that hall in the until Vader shows up. So I wasn't sure if I should add it or not. It did cross my mind tough. I don't know where I can find clean audio of that alarm to add it there plus I feel like the music would drown it out anyway? Thoughts?
I think the camera shake I'm seeing is just that the Rogue One shots are handheld but also there are sparks and fires going off, I do think you could add sounds to imply these are explosions but not necessary.
I do think adding the alarm to the Rogue One side would help hide the seams, even if it's quieter. I did some searching, and if you Google this "Looking for a sound effect : Tantive IV alarm" you'll find a reddit thread with that title where the sound was found isolated, I'm not sure about the quality, I didn't download it myself. Hopefully that helps!