• Most new users don't bother reading our rules. Here's the one that is ignored almost immediately upon signup: DO NOT ASK FOR FANEDIT LINKS PUBLICLY. First, read the FAQ. Seriously. What you want is there. You can also send a message to the editor. If that doesn't work THEN post in the Trade & Request forum. Anywhere else and it will be deleted and an infraction will be issued.
  • If this is your first time here please read our FAQ and Rules pages. They have some useful information that will get us all off on the right foot, especially our Own the Source rule. If you do not understand any of these rules send a private message to one of our staff for further details.
  • Please read our Rules & Guidelines

    Read BEFORE posting Trades & Request

The Book of Boba Fett

Well the 6th episode had some neat moments, but it was yet another mixed bag for me overall. Here's some 'spoiler'-ridden thoughts -

Okay, the 'cliffhanger' that this penultimate episode ended on - 'Grogu having to CHOOSE between learning to be a Jedi or rejoining Mando - is going to be the most important indication of how season 3 of THE MANDALORIAN is going to turn out. If 'Grogu' decides to stay with Luke, then Mando will be freed up to have adventures on his own without having to worry about having the child around anymore. Perhaps he could end up more like a 'lone wolf' kind of character, or perhaps end up with some other form of sidekick partner eventually? Either way, the show might feel refreshed somewhat if it goes down this route.

Additionally. we wouldn't need to see 'Grogu' (or 'deepfake' Luke) again if he chooses this option. and the implication would be that 'Grogu' MIGHT be one of the students that were eventually massacred by Kylo and his followers in THE LAST JEDI movie.... And seeing as Luke is portrayed as being dogmatic about the established Jedi 'rules' of 'attachments' in this latest episode, it adds weight to him beating himself up so much when we see him in that movie - adding to the impression that when he rails against the dogma of the Jedi order to Rey, that he's actually railing against himself and his own dogmatic 'teaching' failures too, and has understandably been brought low and cynical by the deaths it resulted in. Despite disliking the direction that the Sequel Trilogy storyline took with Luke and other characters, there's a part of me that wishes that Disney and co. would go down this 'dark' route, and retire the cutesy character of 'Grogu' altogether at this point, to allow for this possible scenario to tie-in with THE LAST JEDI's 'training temple' outcome. Hell, they were content enough to kill off ALL three of our main heroes from the Original Trilogy after all, so why not?

But the kids needn't worry, as the chances of that happening are ZILTCH....and there's ongoing 'Grogu' merchandising to consider, no doubt....

....and during the previous episode, the mechanic Peli Motto made a point of saying that she had 'hollowed out' the space where an 'astromech droid' would normally fit on Mando's 'starfighter'....so as sure as 'Grogu' is green, I'm gonna guess that he WON'T end up wanting to be a Jedi after all....and that we will see him merrily whizzing around with Mando once again, come that show's next season.....

....and a 'starfighter' toy with little Mando and 'Grogu' figures in it WOULD look pretty neat I suppose.... ;) I just felt sad for the little guy for being made to 'choose' one or the other in the first place....as you just know that he wanted a shot of that little lightsaber so bad!

Anyway, the final episode is also going to determine how good an ending THE BOOK OF BOBA FETT show is getting, and I don't mind admitting that I'm kinda nervous seeing as it's another one by Robert Rodriquez! Hopefully he (and the writers) can come up with something better than his 2 previous episodes - the 'MOD gang' has been very muted since their initial appearance thankfully, and I just hope he doesn't go overboard with any involvement they have in this last episode - someone on another site wished the youths had been given a more grungy, 'Mad Max'-look to them and their bikes overall, rather than looking like something from a trendy 'Coruscant' fashion show....and I agree.

So we'll soon find out if this particular show goes out on a high or not....but either way. I reckon that THE MANDALORIAN show in general is now inextricably linked with this one, and that fans of Mando and 'Grogu' really need to watch both shows to understand things better - especially if Mando and a 'chainmail'-wearing 'Grogu' start off their next season adventures in the 'starfighter'. Still, anything could happen in the finale of THE BOOK OF BOBA FETT, so I'll be watching with interest.

As far as the 'facial look of Luke's scenes in episode 6 go - although not all of them were as convincing as others, there were some that I thought were truly excellent. And some of the musical moments were really great during those scenes too, I thought. I wonder if these were 'Shamook's first 'official' deepfake efforts since joining Lucasfilm? Some terrific work overall, but having studied those scenes a little more, I reckon it's straightforward to shorten some of them to remove the less effective shots I wasn't too keen on, while retaining the ones I liked best.

In fact, there's SO MANY potential ways that the entire show could be cut and re-arranged, that I might play around with it a little more for fun if the final episode makes it worthwhile to me. For instance, instead of showing Boba having 'flashbacks' in his 'bacta tank' inside Jabba's palace right from the off....I quite like the notion of the first episode starting in a much more straightforward, 'linear' way before that aspect of the show is introduced.....so I'd prefer to begin with the Lucasfilm title and the words A long time ago in a galaxy far, far away.... , before kicking things off with a drastically cut-down version of Boba's 'Sarlacc escape' which leaves it open-ended about HOW he actually got out.....and then continue as normal as we see the Jawas steal his armour, then being found by the Tuskens and taken away, right up until he's tormented by the younger Tuskens and stamped on by one of them....before introducing Boba's 'present day' storyline at this point in a certain way I'd prefer....

In the meantime, it just remains to be seen if we see more of 'Machete' and the Rancor or not.... :D
 
Last edited:
I'm almost certain Grogu will choose the Mandalorian over becoming a Jedi. Why? That Naboo starfighter with the Grogu seat.
Book_of_Boba_Fett_mando_ship.jpg




So, are we all ignoring the fact that Grogu was a baby during order 66 and that he might literally be Yoda's son?!?!
 
Huh? No, we're not ignoring that. Where did you get the idea that he was Yoda's son?
Nobody in-universe even knows what species Yoda is, they're allegedly very rare, of course everyone forgets Yaddle is canon, because seriously look at her, but as the only other of their species we've met, knowing the way Hollywood writers think, this theory is probably correct and she (Yaddle) is probably the mother.
 
I'm almost certain Grogu will choose the Mandalorian over becoming a Jedi. Why? That Naboo starfighter with the Grogu seat.
Book_of_Boba_Fett_mando_ship.jpg


I've searched my feelings and know it to be true, alas.

Nobody in-universe even knows what species Yoda is, they're allegedly very rare, of course everyone forgets Yaddle is canon, because seriously look at her, but as the only other of their species we've met, knowing the way Hollywood writers think, this theory is probably correct and she (Yaddle) is probably the mother.

Ugh, down an even darker path that would lead this franchise..... ;)
 
Last edited:
Overall I think the show has been pretty good, though there is a clear disconnect between the episodes that Robert Rodriguez has directed (1 and 3) compared to the rest. He really seems to be having a problem with shooting on the Vision stages, and as a result his episodes tend to be very lifeless (perfectly summed up in the "high speed pursuit" in episode 3). The other episodes have all been great for me, with some great moments learning more about characters and species and some interesting set pieces. The last two Boba-lite episodes have been far and away better than the Boba-centric ones, and I think that purely down to Morrison not being a leading man. He's a capable character actor, but he was asked to do too much and what he was asked to do just wasn't that interesting.

Originally, the show was going to continue the chapter counts from the Mandalorian, and I think that it would have been much better received as such. Also, the 2 Mando episodes should have been spread apart some, as a clear disconnect has now happened with the show and it will be interesting to see if the momentum they've been picking up the last few episodes will carry over into the finale. Of course, Robert Rodriguez is directing so suffice it to say my expectations have been significantly tempered.
 
@hothstation, I'm going to PM you so I can share my thoughts on that. I can see things could take a turn in here and we're all here to discuss The Book of The Mandalorian Boba Fett.
I appreciate you taking the time to do so, along with the energy spent composing your message. Rather than debating the subject matter with you, I will say I respect both you and your opinion.
 
*sigh* Well, it’s over. The action heavy final episode didn’t do much to redeem Rodriguez’s earlier episodes. The action was poorly staged and didn’t have any weight due to good guys constantly getting hit with laser blasts with little or no consequence, meanwhile bad guys going down left and right from the same sorts of shots. We ended up with a predictable conclusion to a storyline that mostly didn’t engage me. Best thing I can say is my kids are happy Grogu will be sticking around.

I hope others enjoyed this series more than me. I’m feeling a steady decline in quality through the first three seasons of Star Wars live action TV. I’m hoping Acolyte or Andor gives the franchise a fresh start set outside this timeframe.

P.S. I have no idea what the post credits scene was about. I’m assuming it is something to do with some expanded universe thing that I don’t follow.

Edit: Nevermind. I guess it’s just the same mod guy who saved Fennec. Not a very consequential scene.
 
Last edited:
I still think this is a salvageable movie even with that ending. I would give the series a C- that can be turned into a solid B+ with better editing and a more streamlined story.
 
I still think this is a salvageable movie even with that ending. I would give the series a C- that can be turned into a solid B+ with better editing and a more streamlined story.
For me it comes down to character investment. I didn’t care about any of the characters. I cared more about IG-11 in Mandalorian than I did about any character in this series. My guess is they knew that was a problem and relied on Mandalorian and Grogu and Luke to bring some character investment to the series. But oddly it just made me care less about those characters. I’m not sure what editing could do to help that. I mean I think editing could perhaps give the action scenes a bit more kinetic energy. But action works best when we care about the characters in the thick of it.
 
Cmon Cad Bane been around since 2009 where my clone wars fans at 😭 To be fair haven't watched BoBF yet wonder if they did him justice

As a Clone Wars/Rebels fan, I was extremely happy with how Cad Bane was handled. His translation from animation to live action is on par with Ahsoka IMO. I didn't know he was going to be in it, but when I saw a stranger walking in the distance, my jaw dropped. Honestly, they left me wanting more of him and that's better than overstaying the welcome.
 
Some thoughts on the finale.....


So the final episode of THE BOOK OF BOBA FETT was another uneven mix of highs and lows for me, and I'd find it difficult to re-watch the entire show in it's existing form again, due to the amount of things that niggled me along the way. However, there were some moments here and there that I really liked too....but it would take a LOT of snipping and rearranging throughout the show to minimise the things that irked me, and to give it a tone more to my own taste overall. For example, a simple thing would be to remove certain moments of Boba's dialogue, so that he's less 'chatty' and remains more of the 'silent type' overall. and trimming some of the 'scooter gang's dialogue would definitely help too.....

It feels like THE MANDALORIAN show's storyline is completely interlinked with this show now....and vice versa....and fans of Mando and Boba would really need to watch BOTH shows to get a complete insight on events involving these characters. Which was a deliberate intention by Disney's writers I guess, although I'd prefer to rearrange some of the Mando/Grogu-centric scenes away from THE BOOK OF BOBA FETT's storyline somewhat. But I'll wait to see how Season 3 of THE MANDALORIAN pans out, to get a better idea of the way I'd choose to go about that.

It's a pity that the Tusken tribe was completely wiped out, as I'd liked to have seen them being involved in fighting the Pyke Syndicate alongside Boba and co.

Although I was aware of what the Cad Bane 'cowboy bounty hunter' character looked like, he was just an 'Expanded Universe'-type character I wasn't invested in, due to never having watched The Clone Wars animated show. However, he fitted in pretty well playing the familiar 'bad gun-for-hire' role for this, and came across as an effectively creepy opponent for Boba I thought.

I generally liked a lot of what we saw concerning the Rancor too, although I'd prefer to cut down on the giant 'Terminator'-like droids and 'scooter gang' antics somewhat. I'm curious to see how season 3 OF THE MANDALORIAN is going to start off, now that a 'Force-trained' Grogu is back in the mix with Mando.

There's plenty of ways that THE BOOK OF BOBA FETT could be re-edited, but no matter what, one thing I'd DEFINITELY prefer to change is the way that the show concludes....

While the final scene of 'Grogu' getting a joyride in Mando's ship was a fun moment to end on, I really disliked the overly-'cuddly' scenes of Boba and Fennec mingling with the locals down 'mainstreet' and meeting with the 'scooter gang' as our last moments with them....so I'd DITCH all of that, as there was already a perfect ending for me before that....where we instead have our final scene with Boba showing him killing Cad Bane then walking away....as we then see Mando failing to control the Rancor before 'Grogu' subdues it and falls asleep....and the show's finale eventually ends with the neat scene of Fennec assassinating the syndicate bosses, the corrupt Mayor, and the Pyke leader....as she exits up the steps, and the door closes behind her to darkness....

boba-fett1x07_3709.jpg

boba-fett1x07_3711.jpg

boba-fett1x07_3717.jpg

boba-fett1x07_3718.jpg

boba-fett1x07_3720.jpg

boba-fett1x07_3721.jpg

boba-fett1x07_3723.jpg

boba-fett1x07_3725.jpg

boba-fett1x07_3726.jpg


So that's the tone I'd prefer to end this show on compared to the existing one, as the music fades down at this point and we then CUT to the 'Directed by Robert Rodriguez' end credit, and the end artwork shots begin.


(and then I'd prefer to REPLACE the 'Cobb Vanth in bacta tank/MOD-ifier guy' scene with the humorous 'Grogu getting a joyride in Mando's ship' scene before we return to the rest of the end credits)
 
Last edited:
Well, that was a crap finale, I'm afraid. There was no real story, just several cycles of pew-pew-pew-Cavalry to the Rescue!. To top it off, we also get an unwelcome return of the absurdly powerful droid shields from the prequels. I liked the series' first few Dances with Tuskens episodes, and the solo Mandalorian hour was very strong, but overall, this season/series is just as much of a narrative mess as the Sequel Trilogy, with just as many baffling narrative swerves, unmotivated cameos, and loose ends. (Remember when this show gave us two uncomfortably close Hutt twins?!)

Dan Murrell lays it all out most excellently here:


And now for a word about Luke. I was one of those who enjoyed seeing him show up at the end of Mando S2 and be heroic, saying he'd give his life for the child. And, fine, maybe he read about the Jedi philosophy of no personal attachments (outside of work friendships with other Jedi, that is) from the Sacred Texts he picked up from Yoda's hut or something. But, as others have pointed out, his whole defining character trait in RotJ was embracing attachment, to the point where he bet his very life on the latent love of his estranged, mass-murdering father. And it worked.

So, why TF is he now strictly enforcing the old Jedi ways of non-attachment? It's totally out of character for him... except, of course, that TLJ has previously established that, up until Rey showed up, he viewed the Jedi Way as a binary: you either buy into the old rules 100%, or you reject it all. Because Rey had to be The Most Specialist Person ever, only she could have the vision to imagine a new, more emotionally healthy kind of Jedi, even though Luke had already proved himself different when he resisted Yoda and Obi-Wan's directives to confront Vader without attempting to redeem him. Ergo, we now get to see Luke being an out-of-character dick in real time, instead of having made that decision long ago as part of the ST backstory. Well, if this is the price we pay for seeing more Luke, I don't like it.


As much as I loathe the Prequel Trilogy, I am intrigued by the idea of an Obi-Wan series, and I guess I'm still interested in Mando S3 and a live-action Thrawn. But that Andor show? Not really, unless they can offer some hook beyond what we already know.
 
Back
Top Bottom