- Messages
- 2,009
- Reaction score
- 2
- Trophy Points
- 51
Thanks for the review mikeveli20, I agree with everything you said. Could you post this review on the site's main page? You can also rate the film out of 10 there. Some people don't seem to realise that a review in the forums doesn't actually get put on the main page automatically.
My feelings exactly.
Also agree whole heartedly. But to be honest, watchable was my intention. You can't make ox, mac, mutt etc into great characters, you can only remove the parts that make you want to stab your eyes out and hope you are left with something decent enough to enjoy.
Cheers.
Sorry, that was personal preference and I knew not everyone would be into it. I love hearing the score smashing the speakers. When that indy theme kicks in, I want it to shake the walls. Again, personal preference and I knew not everyone would be into it.
I agree with this too. The film was so bad, I knew it wouldn't become a great film. But there are moments in there I really enjoy, and I personally find this version far more watchable.
Thanks heaps, there's another one on the way as we speak. Cheers for taking the time to review the film, it's great to get feedback from a fellow Indy fan.
this is as good as it's going to get
My feelings exactly.
At its core, it's still a pretty bad movie, but at least with this version it
becomes watchable. You got rid of everything you possibly could without really
affecting the flow of the story (still a bad story no matter what).
Also agree whole heartedly. But to be honest, watchable was my intention. You can't make ox, mac, mutt etc into great characters, you can only remove the parts that make you want to stab your eyes out and hope you are left with something decent enough to enjoy.
I watched the AVCHD version and the video and audio quality was excellent.
Cheers.
My main complaint about the audio is that the replaced score is LOUD
Sorry, that was personal preference and I knew not everyone would be into it. I love hearing the score smashing the speakers. When that indy theme kicks in, I want it to shake the walls. Again, personal preference and I knew not everyone would be into it.
As far as entertainment value, I'd probably still only give this movie a 6/10,
but that's much higher than the 2/10 I would give the original. It feels more
Indy-like and Indy himself is less of a caricature and more like we remember
him.
I agree with this too. The film was so bad, I knew it wouldn't become a great film. But there are moments in there I really enjoy, and I personally find this version far more watchable.
Looking forward to seeing some of your future edits.
Thanks heaps, there's another one on the way as we speak. Cheers for taking the time to review the film, it's great to get feedback from a fellow Indy fan.