- Messages
- 7,891
- Reaction score
- 6
- Trophy Points
- 83
True Romance - The Tarantino Cut (new extended & recut version)
by Spoke
Think you've seen True Romance? Think again.
You certainly haven't seen the film that its writer envisioned.
The original screenplay by Quentin Tarantino, much like his Reservoir Dogs and Pulp Fiction, had an answers-first, questions-later structure to it. And that, more than anything else, was what made it interesting.
True Romance was written, very carefully written, to be a non-linear story. And Tony Scott, the director, shot it that way. But at some point during the editing process, Scott got cold feet. Worried that the audience wouldn't understand the movie, he decided to put all the scenes in chronological order.
And he ruined the film.
The story of True Romance was supposed to be divided into three parts. Part one: the characters know more than the audience. Part two: the audience catches up. Part three: the audience knows more than the characters.
By putting the film in chronological order, Scott spoiled everything. Say goodbye to all the surprises and say goodbye to anything approaching subtlety. Say hello to dialogue that's repetitious and pointless.
This is especially true of the early part of the movie, where every line was meant to tease the viewer and slowly dole out information. Scott took that away.
All this to say that assembling a 'Tarantino' cut of True Romance has been a long held dream of mine.
Using the original screenplay as a guide, and re-inserting as much cut footage as possible, this new version of the film is probably the closest any of us will ever get to seeing Tarantino's vision.
With the scenes of the film back in their proper non-linear order, small throwaway lines are suddenly much more meaningful, and otherwise minor sequences suddenly become quite relevant.
The deleted scenes are also worth mentioning. Quite a bit was cut from the theatrical release. Dialogue that was deemed too nasty, or scenes that served as bridges in the original structure were all removed.
The saddest, most inexcusable victim of the Scott cut would have to be the character of Alabama. For reasons (at least to my knowledge) unknown, Scott left most of her best moments on the cutting room floor. Several scenes where she talks with Clarence, tells him stories about herself, or just plain explains where her head is at, were inexplicably omitted.
But that's the beauty of fan edits. In this new cut, everything is restored. The scenes all return to their proper place, and Alabama gets the screen time she always deserved.
Oh, and the ending is fixed, too. Gone is the happy happy 'Magic eye patch, frolicking on the beach, Elvis Junior' ending. We return instead to Tarantino's much nastier, much more satisfying finale.
Before I go, I'd like to mention that I did't like True Romance very much when I first saw it. Other than the Hopper/Walken scene, and Oldman's trippy performance, I thought it was fairly forgettable. Just a boy meets girl story.
Sure, the boy was psychotic and the girl was a hooker and they kill or are responsible for the deaths of nearly every person they meet, but that's besides the point. It just didn't do much for me. Of course, at the time, I didn't know that it had been so severely mangled. At the time, all I knew was that it didn't have that spark that made Tarantino's other work sing.
Well, now it hits the high notes. You're welcome.
I've been waiting fifteen years for someone at the studio to wise up and realize that there's money to be made from a 'Tarantino' cut of True Romance. Fact is, I'm pretty sure that if someone put the work in, this would surely merit a re-release in theaters. Hey, if a less good version of Donnie Darko can get one, 'The Tarantino cut' of True Romance should be a shoe-in.
Thanks for listening.
Feel free to send any praise, complaints, or legal threats to:
[email protected]
Assembly map:
[spoiler:3m1fq17k]The title cards were made to match, in font and size, the ones that appear in Pulp Fiction and Reservoir Dogs. Transitions, fades to black and sound transitions, mimick the style used by Sally Menke, Tarantino's editor on all his movies.
All excerpts from Disk 2 are from deleted scenes.
01 - Disk 1 - 0:00 to 4:50 (fade out before narration begins)
INSERT TITLE CARD: MOTORCITY
02 - Disk 2 - Drexyl Does Business (3:32)
03 - Disk 1 - 34:23 to 40:23 (up to : Son of a bitch.)
INSERT TITLE CARD: HOLLYWOOD
04 - Disk 1 - 40:23 to 58:21 (up to : Boss, get ready to get happy.)
INSERT TITLE CARD: CLARENCE AND ALABAMA HIT L.A.
05 - Disk 1 - 58:21 to 59:50 (up to : screaming woman on tv)
06 - Disk 2 - An Amazing Girl (1:30)
07 - Disk 1 - 1:00:19 to1:00:44 (up to : So what are you doing in L.A. anyway?)
INSERT TITLE CARD: DETROIT, TWO WEEKS EARLIER
08 - Disk 2 - At The Movies (3:28)
Footage from "The Streetfighter" has been inserted over the original footage because the credit "Directed by Ridley Scott" originally appeared over the image and since this scene now appears in the middle of the movie it made no sense and had to be covered up. Interestingly enough, the dub used in True Romance is different from the copy I used. Also, the sequence as it appears in the movie was re-edited out of sequence for some reason. The editing was made to match what appears in the original movie.
09 - Disk 1 - 8 :45 to 13 :11 (up to : sex and billboard shot)
10 - Disk 2 - He Really Loved Her (1:20)
11 - Disk 2 - Coming Clean (5:07)
12 - Disk 1 - 17:38 to 19 :05 (up to : A son of a bitch like that)
13 - Disk 1 - 20:42 to 24:29 (up to : I love you too.)
INSERT TITLE CARD: CASS QUARTER, HEART OF DETROIT
14 - Disk 1 - 24:29 to 34:21 (up to : These aren't my clothes)
15 - Disk 2 - No cheers (4 :32)
16 - Disk 1 - 1:03:55 to 1:27:45 (up to : We just want the collar. - You got it.)
17 - Disk 2 - Vincenzo's vendetta (1:42)
INSERT TITLE CARD: THE BIG DAY
18 - Disk 1 - 1:27:46 to 1:31:09 (up to : And some cleaning products.)
19 - Disk 2 - We Know What We're Doing (2:16)
20 - Disk 2 - Playing What If (1 :59)
21 - Disk 2 - Elliot's Motivation(1 :12)
22 - Disk 1 - 1:35:13 to 1:51:03 (up to : Sweetie!)
23 - Disk 2 - alternate ending (6:20)
The alternate ending features flashback scenes that are slightly longer to cover the missing footage that was replaced with storyboards on the deleted scenes of the DVD.[/spoiler:3m1fq17k]
by Spoke
Think you've seen True Romance? Think again.
You certainly haven't seen the film that its writer envisioned.
The original screenplay by Quentin Tarantino, much like his Reservoir Dogs and Pulp Fiction, had an answers-first, questions-later structure to it. And that, more than anything else, was what made it interesting.
True Romance was written, very carefully written, to be a non-linear story. And Tony Scott, the director, shot it that way. But at some point during the editing process, Scott got cold feet. Worried that the audience wouldn't understand the movie, he decided to put all the scenes in chronological order.
And he ruined the film.
The story of True Romance was supposed to be divided into three parts. Part one: the characters know more than the audience. Part two: the audience catches up. Part three: the audience knows more than the characters.
By putting the film in chronological order, Scott spoiled everything. Say goodbye to all the surprises and say goodbye to anything approaching subtlety. Say hello to dialogue that's repetitious and pointless.
This is especially true of the early part of the movie, where every line was meant to tease the viewer and slowly dole out information. Scott took that away.
All this to say that assembling a 'Tarantino' cut of True Romance has been a long held dream of mine.
Using the original screenplay as a guide, and re-inserting as much cut footage as possible, this new version of the film is probably the closest any of us will ever get to seeing Tarantino's vision.
With the scenes of the film back in their proper non-linear order, small throwaway lines are suddenly much more meaningful, and otherwise minor sequences suddenly become quite relevant.
The deleted scenes are also worth mentioning. Quite a bit was cut from the theatrical release. Dialogue that was deemed too nasty, or scenes that served as bridges in the original structure were all removed.
The saddest, most inexcusable victim of the Scott cut would have to be the character of Alabama. For reasons (at least to my knowledge) unknown, Scott left most of her best moments on the cutting room floor. Several scenes where she talks with Clarence, tells him stories about herself, or just plain explains where her head is at, were inexplicably omitted.
But that's the beauty of fan edits. In this new cut, everything is restored. The scenes all return to their proper place, and Alabama gets the screen time she always deserved.
Oh, and the ending is fixed, too. Gone is the happy happy 'Magic eye patch, frolicking on the beach, Elvis Junior' ending. We return instead to Tarantino's much nastier, much more satisfying finale.
Before I go, I'd like to mention that I did't like True Romance very much when I first saw it. Other than the Hopper/Walken scene, and Oldman's trippy performance, I thought it was fairly forgettable. Just a boy meets girl story.
Sure, the boy was psychotic and the girl was a hooker and they kill or are responsible for the deaths of nearly every person they meet, but that's besides the point. It just didn't do much for me. Of course, at the time, I didn't know that it had been so severely mangled. At the time, all I knew was that it didn't have that spark that made Tarantino's other work sing.
Well, now it hits the high notes. You're welcome.
I've been waiting fifteen years for someone at the studio to wise up and realize that there's money to be made from a 'Tarantino' cut of True Romance. Fact is, I'm pretty sure that if someone put the work in, this would surely merit a re-release in theaters. Hey, if a less good version of Donnie Darko can get one, 'The Tarantino cut' of True Romance should be a shoe-in.
Thanks for listening.
Feel free to send any praise, complaints, or legal threats to:
[email protected]
Assembly map:
[spoiler:3m1fq17k]The title cards were made to match, in font and size, the ones that appear in Pulp Fiction and Reservoir Dogs. Transitions, fades to black and sound transitions, mimick the style used by Sally Menke, Tarantino's editor on all his movies.
All excerpts from Disk 2 are from deleted scenes.
01 - Disk 1 - 0:00 to 4:50 (fade out before narration begins)
INSERT TITLE CARD: MOTORCITY
02 - Disk 2 - Drexyl Does Business (3:32)
03 - Disk 1 - 34:23 to 40:23 (up to : Son of a bitch.)
INSERT TITLE CARD: HOLLYWOOD
04 - Disk 1 - 40:23 to 58:21 (up to : Boss, get ready to get happy.)
INSERT TITLE CARD: CLARENCE AND ALABAMA HIT L.A.
05 - Disk 1 - 58:21 to 59:50 (up to : screaming woman on tv)
06 - Disk 2 - An Amazing Girl (1:30)
07 - Disk 1 - 1:00:19 to1:00:44 (up to : So what are you doing in L.A. anyway?)
INSERT TITLE CARD: DETROIT, TWO WEEKS EARLIER
08 - Disk 2 - At The Movies (3:28)
Footage from "The Streetfighter" has been inserted over the original footage because the credit "Directed by Ridley Scott" originally appeared over the image and since this scene now appears in the middle of the movie it made no sense and had to be covered up. Interestingly enough, the dub used in True Romance is different from the copy I used. Also, the sequence as it appears in the movie was re-edited out of sequence for some reason. The editing was made to match what appears in the original movie.
09 - Disk 1 - 8 :45 to 13 :11 (up to : sex and billboard shot)
10 - Disk 2 - He Really Loved Her (1:20)
11 - Disk 2 - Coming Clean (5:07)
12 - Disk 1 - 17:38 to 19 :05 (up to : A son of a bitch like that)
13 - Disk 1 - 20:42 to 24:29 (up to : I love you too.)
INSERT TITLE CARD: CASS QUARTER, HEART OF DETROIT
14 - Disk 1 - 24:29 to 34:21 (up to : These aren't my clothes)
15 - Disk 2 - No cheers (4 :32)
16 - Disk 1 - 1:03:55 to 1:27:45 (up to : We just want the collar. - You got it.)
17 - Disk 2 - Vincenzo's vendetta (1:42)
INSERT TITLE CARD: THE BIG DAY
18 - Disk 1 - 1:27:46 to 1:31:09 (up to : And some cleaning products.)
19 - Disk 2 - We Know What We're Doing (2:16)
20 - Disk 2 - Playing What If (1 :59)
21 - Disk 2 - Elliot's Motivation(1 :12)
22 - Disk 1 - 1:35:13 to 1:51:03 (up to : Sweetie!)
23 - Disk 2 - alternate ending (6:20)
The alternate ending features flashback scenes that are slightly longer to cover the missing footage that was replaced with storyboards on the deleted scenes of the DVD.[/spoiler:3m1fq17k]