Read BEFORE posting Trades & Request
TVs Frink said:I won't watch any edit that removes Holdo.
L8wrtr said:TVs Frink said:I won't watch any edit that removes Holdo.
I won't watch any edit that includes The Last Jedi.
theforce said:Luke hands the light saber over to Rey rather than throwing it over his shoulder. If you follow his channel...he explains his decision as to why.
By far his edit is bold and ambitious...in my opinion not seen since the Phantom Editor....that's my two cents worth.
He got rid of the stupid and idiotic Hux "hello, are you there" scene. What nonsense.
TVs Frink said:L8wrtr said:TVs Frink said:I won't watch any edit that removes Holdo.
I won't watch any edit that includes The Last Jedi.
You make me sad.
Masirimso17 said:@"CathyFulcherBaker" is the anti-Ivan Ortega and does what he does a million times better. She’s fair, modest, and genuine. But I digress.
CathyFulcherBaker said:Masirimso17 said:@"CathyFulcherBaker" is the anti-Ivan Ortega and does what he does a million times better. She’s fair, modest, and genuine. But I digress.
You have made my day and I thank you for it. <3 Kinda makes me wanna do a TLJ edit now... I don't know, I don't feel confident that I will definitely have anything new to add.
jrWHAG42 said:It's not about adding, it's about removing.
CathyFulcherBaker said:jrWHAG42 said:It's not about adding, it's about removing.
I just want to clarify that I didn't mean "adding new footage" I meant "What would my fan edit do what others haven't done before? What am I adding to this film by making these edits if they have (likely) already been done?"
Zarius said:There's an edit on OT.com called the "Clean Cut" which has interesting ideas like Luke being responsible for saving Leia in space and force-controlling her, but the editing needs work, there's a big cut to blackness when Luke learns of Hal, and then a dissolve to him outside the hut.
BandobrasTuk said:Zarius said:There's an edit on OT.com called the "Clean Cut" which has interesting ideas like Luke being responsible for saving Leia in space and force-controlling her, but the editing needs work, there's a big cut to blackness when Luke learns of Hal, and then a dissolve to him outside the hut.
He had worked on that and V3 is up for watching and some feedback.
Belgarath said:Rekindled so far is my favorite edit of TLJ. It's basically Hal's Legendary with additional cuts: No space walking. No Finn vs. Phasma fight. Rose doesn't save Finn. It's nice.