• Most new users don't bother reading our rules. Here's the one that is ignored almost immediately upon signup: DO NOT ASK FOR FANEDIT LINKS PUBLICLY. First, read the FAQ. Seriously. What you want is there. You can also send a message to the editor. If that doesn't work THEN post in the Trade & Request forum. Anywhere else and it will be deleted and an infraction will be issued.
  • If this is your first time here please read our FAQ and Rules pages. They have some useful information that will get us all off on the right foot. More details on our policies, especially our Own the Source rule are available here. If you do not understand any of these rules send a private message to one of our staff for further details.
  • Favorite Edit of the Year (FEOTY) 2020 Awards are here.

The Fanedit Collection - The Black Spines

TheTVEditor

Well-known member
Messages
99
Reaction score
99
Trophy Points
33
This is just some covers that I did for my own fanedit DVD collection, so I thought why not share them here. They are really simple (maybe quite generic) but I like it, the black spines were done for patterning purposes. Some are IFDB edits, some are not. All credits goes for @theryaney for the wonderful Criterion-styled covers, that I just tweaked a bit.


The covers contained in this gallery are as follows:
  • 2010 - A Space Epilogue
  • A.I. - The Kubrick Edit (non-IFBD)
  • Avengers - Assembled
  • Bateman Begins - An American Psycho
  • Batman - Gotham's Knight (non-IFBD)
  • Batman Forever - The Red Book Edition
  • Bram Stoker's Dracula - The Silent Version
  • Cosmogony
  • Darkly Dreaming Dexter
  • Dune - Deluxe Edition
  • Dune - The Alternative Edition Redux
  • Frank Hebert's Dune - The Spence Edit
  • Game of Thrones - Film I: A Tale of Kings and Honor
  • Game of Thrones - Film II: A Storm of Swords
  • Game of Thrones - Film III: A Feast for Crows
  • Game of Thrones - Film IV: A Roar for Vengeance
  • IT - A Film
  • Justice League Grindhoused
  • Kill Bill - The Shogun Assassin's Cut (non-IFBD)
  • Kill Bill - The Whole Bloody Affair (TheMilkmanConspiracy's Version)
  • Once Upon a Time in Hollywood - The Red Apple Cut
  • Pulp Empire
  • The Beast in Me
  • The Godfather - Don Vito's Opus
  • The Godfather - Michael's Opus
  • The Hobbit - The Book Edit (non-IFBD, yet)
  • The Hobbit - The Maple Films Edit
  • The Hobbit - The Two-Hour Edit (non-IFBD)
  • The Killer Bride
  • The Killer Bride - The Japanese Cut
  • The Titanic
  • There and Back Again - A Hobbit's Tale (Matt Skuta's edit) (non-IFBD)
  • Twin Peaks - Fire Walk With Me: Teresa Banks and The Last Seven Days of Laura Palmer
  • William Must Die
  • Wizardhood (non-IFBD)

I made those cover using some poster I found online on The Poster Database, some I did myself (or modified in some way), and some are the original poster of the edits. There are more that I will eventually do for some of the edits that I have here, and I will post it (maybe in the same gallery or in a second one).
 
Last edited:

Wraith

Well-known member
Donor
Faneditor
Messages
1,112
Reaction score
498
Trophy Points
103
Really Nice work, and I have a bunch of these edits ...so HERE WE GO-A-PRINTING....

Flattered you included The Godfather Magnum Opus titles...
 

TheTVEditor

Well-known member
Messages
99
Reaction score
99
Trophy Points
33
Really Nice work, and I have a bunch of these edits ...so HERE WE GO-A-PRINTING....

Flattered you included The Godfather Magnum Opus titles...
If we had a Criterion Collection of fanedits, yours probably would have a nice place on it ;)
 

Wraith

Well-known member
Donor
Faneditor
Messages
1,112
Reaction score
498
Trophy Points
103
We do have a "Criterion Collection" so to speak, thanks to your efforts....works for me...

Maybe we should have a poll of some sorts....everyone picks their top 10, and collate scoring based on cumulataive positioning... or take review rankings...which is a tad more objective...#

or a blend of both 50:50....weighting, and the top 50 make the grade...

Just a thought
 
Last edited:

Wraith

Well-known member
Donor
Faneditor
Messages
1,112
Reaction score
498
Trophy Points
103
The Geekterion Collection
 

TheTVEditor

Well-known member
Messages
99
Reaction score
99
Trophy Points
33
We do have a "Criterion Collection" so to speak, thanks to your efforts....works for me...

Maybe we should have a poll of some sorts....everyone picks their top 10, and collate scoring based on cumulataive positioning... or take review rankings...which is a tad more objective...#

or a blend of both 50:50....weighting, and the top 50 make the grade...

Just a thought
Wonder if we should have spine n⁰, but it's a tad unlikely I think...
 

Wraith

Well-known member
Donor
Faneditor
Messages
1,112
Reaction score
498
Trophy Points
103
Spine numbers in rank order..
Tie break no. of reviews then review rank then top ten ranking lowest scores…. Since lower the score, higher the rank…1 point for top slot, 2 points for second and so on…
 

Wraith

Well-known member
Donor
Faneditor
Messages
1,112
Reaction score
498
Trophy Points
103
VOTE 1
1 edit a
2 edit b
3 edit c

VOTE 2

1 Edit a
2 Edit c
3 Edit b

Scores from POLL

Edit A 2
edit b 5
Edit c 5

All Reviews average (minimum 4 reviews)
Edit A 9.9
Edit c 9.7
edit b 9.6

FINAL POSITIONS/ SPINE NUMBERS

Edit a 001
Edit c 002
edit b 003


too complex?
 
Last edited:

TheTVEditor

Well-known member
Messages
99
Reaction score
99
Trophy Points
33
VOTE 1
1 edit a
2 edit b
3 edit c

VOTE 2

1 Edit a
2 Edit c
3 Edit b

Scores from POLL

Edit A 2
edit b 5
Edit c 5

All Reviews average (minimum 4 reviews)
Edit A 9.9
Edit c 9.7
edit b 9.6

FINAL POSITIONS/ SPINE NUMBERS

Edit a 001
Edit c 002
edit b 003

too complex?
I do think is too complex, the best idea were to be a release date order, so The Phantom Edit for instance (that I am going to upload the cover for it someday) would be spine n⁰1, but for that we would still have a list of every single one fanedit ever uploaded online, from IFDb, Original Trilogy, YouTube,Vimeo, original sites, Reddit, etc. In my honest opinion that would be the best spine order. Or just, you know, don't have a spine order and let people order as they wish (but spine n⁰ would be very neat still)
 

Wraith

Well-known member
Donor
Faneditor
Messages
1,112
Reaction score
498
Trophy Points
103
I like release order… maybe a review rating threshold, and if over, it get the next spine number in release order. Agree Phantom edit is 001
 

TheTVEditor

Well-known member
Messages
99
Reaction score
99
Trophy Points
33
I like release order… maybe a review rating threshold, and if over, it get the next spine number in release order. Agree Phantom edit is 001
Just found out that there's actually a list of all online edits on Reddit done by @Heavisyde , apparently the first ever fanedit online was Matrix: Rebirth - The UNIGMA Cut released in 2000, although I don't see A.I. - The Kubrick Edit released in 2002 and edits like Eyes Wide Cut, and edits from march 2021 to now are nowhere to be seen.

Still, a really noble endeavor for someone to endure, if we go by this list, over 3000 edits are online, surpassing even the Criterion Collection.
 

Last Impressions

Well-known member
Donor
Faneditor
Messages
565
Reaction score
122
Trophy Points
63
This is just some covers that I did for my own fanedit DVD collection, so I thought why not share them here. They are really simple (maybe quite generic) but I like it, the black spines were done for patterning purposes. Some are IFDB edits, some are not. All credits goes for @theryaney for the wonderful Criterion-styled covers, that I just tweaked a bit.


The covers contained in this gallery are as follows:
  • 2010 - A Space Epilogue
  • A.I. - The Kubrick Edit (non-IFBD)
  • Avengers - Assembled
  • Bateman Begins - An American Psycho
  • Batman - Gotham's Knight (non-IFBD)
  • Batman Forever - The Red Book Edition
  • Bram Stoker's Dracula - The Silent Version
  • Cosmogony
  • Darkly Dreaming Dexter
  • Dune - Deluxe Edition
  • Dune - The Alternative Edition Redux
  • Frank Hebert's Dune - The Spence Edit
  • Game of Thrones - Film I: A Tale of Kings and Honor
  • Game of Thrones - Film II: A Storm of Swords
  • Game of Thrones - Film III: A Feast for Crows
  • Game of Thrones - Film IV: A Roar for Vengeance
  • IT - A Film
  • Justice League Grindhoused
  • Kill Bill - The Shogun Assassin's Cut (non-IFBD)
  • Kill Bill - The Whole Bloody Affair (TheMilkmanConspiracy's Version)
  • Once Upon a Time in Hollywood - The Red Apple Cut
  • Pulp Empire
  • The Beast in Me
  • The Godfather - Don Vito's Opus
  • The Godfather - Michael's Opus
  • The Hobbit - The Book Edit (non-IFBD, yet)
  • The Hobbit - The Maple Films Edit
  • The Hobbit - The Two-Hour Edit (non-IFBD)
  • The Killer Bride
  • The Killer Bride - The Japanese Cut
  • The Titanic
  • There and Back Again - A Hobbit's Tale (Matt Skuta's edit) (non-IFBD)
  • Twin Peaks - Fire Walk With Me: Teresa Banks and The Last Seven Days of Laura Palmer
  • William Must Die
  • Wizardhood (non-IFBD)

I made those cover using some poster I found online on The Poster Database, some I did myself (or modified in some way), and some are the original poster of the edits. There are more that I will eventually do for some of the edits that I have here, and I will post it (maybe in the same gallery or in a second one).
These are great - i do love the style of the Fanedit collection covers and have made a few for my own edits. They look great on the shelf. Are you able to make printable BLURAY covers for these...i'd love to print a few.
 

TheTVEditor

Well-known member
Messages
99
Reaction score
99
Trophy Points
33
These are great - i do love the style of the Fanedit collection covers and have made a few for my own edits. They look great on the shelf. Are you able to make printable BLURAY covers for these...i'd love to print a few.
Sure thing! I'll just complete some more DVD covers for my collection, and then start to working on the BD covers.
 

Heavisyde

Well-known member
Faneditor
Messages
284
Reaction score
101
Trophy Points
58
Just found out that there's actually a list of all online edits on Reddit done by @Heavisyde , apparently the first ever fanedit online was Matrix: Rebirth - The UNIGMA Cut released in 2000, although I don't see A.I. - The Kubrick Edit released in 2002 and edits like Eyes Wide Cut, and edits from march 2021 to now are nowhere to be seen.

Still, a really noble endeavor for someone to endure, if we go by this list, over 3000 edits are online, surpassing even the Criterion Collection.
Thanks for pointing those out to me, I've added The Kubrick Edit and Eyes Wide Cut to the list. WIth regards to the Unigma Cut, that was releaed on VHS in 2000 but online in 2009, so I've moved that down the list. I believe The Phantom Edit was indeed the first edit to be released online. Haven't updated it regularly since March 2021, it's mostly complete up until that date.
 

TheTVEditor

Well-known member
Messages
99
Reaction score
99
Trophy Points
33
A new batch of DVD covers, there are a 32 that I have to do yet, and then I will rework them into BD covers. (There are some edits that are fanedits from streaming TV shows, which I don't know if it's permitted, if it's not, I'll remove them as soon as possible!)


The covers contained in this gallery are as follows:
  • Blade Runner - Danse Macabre
  • Blade Runner 2049 - Aerodynamik
  • Caligula - Orgy of Power (non-IFBD)
  • Chainsaw Devil
  • Derelict
  • Dream Maniac
  • Finest Hour - A Supercut of Dunkirk and Darkest Hour
  • Halloween - Homecoming (This is not the LastSurvivor edit, but the Cole Edits cut) (non-IFBD)
  • Hannibal - The Chesapeake Ripper (non-IFBD)
  • Hannibal - The Memory Palace (non-IFBD)
  • Icarus
  • IT - The Bookish Edit
  • Jaws - The Sharksploitation Edit
  • Mindhunter - The Profiler Edit (non-IFBD)
  • Never Say McClory Again Remastered (non-IFBD, only the SD version)
  • Order of the Peaky Blinders
  • Paradise
  • Prometheus - Giftbearer
  • Rob Zombie's Halloween (non-IFBD)
  • Robots vs. Kung Fu - The Matrix Grindhouse Edition
  • Star Wars - 30's Silent Edition: Episodes I-III
  • Star Wars - 30's Silent Edition: Episodes IV-VI
  • Star Wars - Silent Edition: Episodes VII
  • Star Wars - Abridged I: The Republic
  • Star Wars - Abridged II: The Rebellion
  • Star Wars - Despecialized Edition
  • The Empire Strikes Back - Despecialized Edition
  • Return of the Jedi - Despecialized Edition
  • Star Wars - Episode I.II: The Phantom Edit
  • Star Wars - Episode II.I: Attack of the Phantom
  • Star Wars - Rise of the Rebellion
  • Tears in the Rain
  • The Grasshopper Lies Heavy (non-IFBD)
  • The Mandalorian: Episode I - A Vergence in the Force (non-IFBD)
  • The Night of Samhain
  • The Thief and the Cobbler - The Recobbled Cut
  • The War of the Stars - A New Hope Grindhoused
  • The War of the Stars II - The Future in Motion
  • The Witcher - The Last Wish (non-IFBD)
  • The Witcher - Sword of Destiny (non-IFBD)
 

Darth Kermit

Well-known member
Messages
54
Reaction score
24
Trophy Points
23
Some great artwork! I can’t wait to see your Blu-Ray versions as I have many of these fanedits in my collection. And as to the streaming service edits, I know that editing those can’t be discussed or approved, as you can’t own the source, but I’m not sure the rules on artwork. You are not spreading the edit, just making cover art for it, and showing that. However I’m not an admin, so I’m sure someone will correct me if I am wrong.
 

pranafilms

Well-known member
Messages
69
Reaction score
5
Trophy Points
13
A new batch of DVD covers, there are a 32 that I have to do yet, and then I will rework them into BD covers. (There are some edits that are fanedits from streaming TV shows, which I don't know if it's permitted, if it's not, I'll remove them as soon as possible!)


The covers contained in this gallery are as follows:
  • Blade Runner - Danse Macabre
  • Blade Runner 2049 - Aerodynamik
  • Caligula - Orgy of Power (non-IFBD)
  • Chainsaw Devil
  • Derelict
  • Dream Maniac
  • Finest Hour - A Supercut of Dunkirk and Darkest Hour
  • Halloween - Homecoming (This is not the LastSurvivor edit, but the Cole Edits cut) (non-IFBD)
  • Hannibal - The Chesapeake Ripper (non-IFBD)
  • Hannibal - The Memory Palace (non-IFBD)
  • Icarus
  • IT - The Bookish Edit
  • Jaws - The Sharksploitation Edit
  • Mindhunter - The Profiler Edit (non-IFBD)
  • Never Say McClory Again Remastered (non-IFBD, only the SD version)
  • Order of the Peaky Blinders
  • Paradise
  • Prometheus - Giftbearer
  • Rob Zombie's Halloween (non-IFBD)
  • Robots vs. Kung Fu - The Matrix Grindhouse Edition
  • Star Wars - 30's Silent Edition: Episodes I-III
  • Star Wars - 30's Silent Edition: Episodes IV-VI
  • Star Wars - Silent Edition: Episodes VII
  • Star Wars - Abridged I: The Republic
  • Star Wars - Abridged II: The Rebellion
  • Star Wars - Despecialized Edition
  • The Empire Strikes Back - Despecialized Edition
  • Return of the Jedi - Despecialized Edition
  • Star Wars - Episode I.II: The Phantom Edit
  • Star Wars - Episode II.I: Attack of the Phantom
  • Star Wars - Rise of the Rebellion
  • Tears in the Rain
  • The Grasshopper Lies Heavy (non-IFBD)
  • The Mandalorian: Episode I - A Vergence in the Force (non-IFBD)
  • The Night of Samhain
  • The Thief and the Cobbler - The Recobbled Cut
  • The War of the Stars - A New Hope Grindhoused
  • The War of the Stars II - The Future in Motion
  • The Witcher - The Last Wish (non-IFBD)
  • The Witcher - Sword of Destiny (non-IFBD)

I am loving these and I am waiting to see the BluRay versions too. I love the Star Wars Despecialized covers, cause they remind me of the VHS covers of the original trilogy that I grew up with.

hsE2N9O.jpeg


Very cool.

I Love the whole collection aspect, as I am a fan of the Criterion Collection too. I even tried to make covers too, and your Cosmogony cover knocks mine out of the park; in a good way. :)

Keep on the good work.
 
Top Bottom