lpd said:
These people should be allowed to make a full movie.
Someone should start a pettition.
The cinematic trailers are amazing.
I think it is curious that the reception is so overwhelmingly positive - don't get me wrong I think they look nice as well and the backstory will probably fleshed out but it is still a difference if you make a trailer for a game or a film
I'm betting you a million peggats that had george lucas released the very same clip people would complain about the following:
characters are one-dimensional
there is no emotional struggle other than "he's bad we're good"
shamelessly cashing in on our nostalgia by using phrases like "fastest ship ... yada"
over the top style over substance
the list goes on
While I agree that all cinematic trailers were nice teaser the language of PC-intros and movies is still a different one and as a movie this would turn out the same as the prequels