Perhaps NumeralJoker has done this with his Cinematic Cuts?Hi all, I know some had said in the past that they were considering taking over this project for Smudger. Has anything come of this? The way I figure it, there would be 4 movies left:
An edit consisting of Mortis and the Citadel arcs
A season 5 edit consisting of the Maul/Mandalore arc and The Ahsoka 'Wrong Jedi' arc
A season 6 edit consisting of the Clone and Yoda arcs
A season 7 edit consisting of the Bad Batch and Ahsoka arcs
I purposely left the finale off this list as in my mind the perfect way to do that has already been done, with Madman's Knowledge splicing together of the finale and Episode III into one.
I severely lack the technical editing skill to create my own edits, but if an experienced editor were willing to continue these in Smudger's style, I would be more than willing to help plan out and storyboard the installments. Any takers?
#staffA season 7 edit consisting of the Bad Batch and Ahsoka arcs
I hate to tear people's work apart, especially fans creating these labors of love. That being said, I've tried watching a couple Numeral Joker edits, and tried skimming others. People love them because they're comprehensive and in 4k, but from what I saw they seem...not the best edited. Cuts are far from seamless, and their 52 or however many edits of Clone Wars just seem to feel like episodes strung together with no effort to make them actually feel like movies. They definitely don't seem to hold up to the standards set by Smudger. Not to say that they're bad, if that's all you're looking for then it's not a problem. I just personally wouldn't consider them a replacement or followup to Smudger's edits.Perhaps NumeralJoker has done this with his Cinematic Cuts?
are you thinking of the 9-film edit by reddit user drdoomblunt? i should get around to watching theseOn another note, there was someone on Reddit who made 9 edits spanning the whole series, I believe they mentioned that they were inspired by Smudger. I watched their first edit which seemed promising, and have yet to watch the others. I wish I could remember the name of the editor.
That's the one!are you thinking of the 9-film edit by reddit user drdoomblunt? i should get around to watching these
I hate to tear people's work apart, especially fans creating these labors of love. That being said, I've tried watching a couple Numeral Joker edits, and tried skimming others. People love them because they're comprehensive and in 4k, but from what I saw they seem...not the best edited. Cuts are far from seamless, and their 52 or however many edits of Clone Wars just seem to feel like episodes strung together with no effort to make them actually feel like movies. They definitely don't seem to hold up to the standards set by Smudger. Not to say that they're bad, if that's all you're looking for then it's not a problem. I just personally wouldn't consider them a replacement or followup to Smudger's edits.
But! I would love for someone to tell me that I'm wrong, that I haven't looked at the best of their edits, or what have you. I have no problem reassessing.
On another note, there was someone on Reddit who made 9 edits spanning the whole series, I believe they mentioned that they were inspired by Smudger. I watched their first edit which seemed promising, and have yet to watch the others. I wish I could remember the name of the editor.