- Messages
- 546
- Reaction score
- 1
- Trophy Points
- 21
So, I've been wanting to watch one of the Dune fanedits but who's is the one to watch? At 3 hours apiece I'm wondering if any of y'all have seen all 4 and if so who's did you like the best? :???:
TV's Frink said:I misread this topic as "Dude, which one do you like the best?"
WrathofLucas said:How does "Dune: The Alternative Edition Redux " compare to the other fanedits?
I've only seen 3rd Stage and thought it was great. I've heard good things about Redux but read that the thought monologues have been removed. That was one of my favourite things about the Lynch version!
TV's Frink said:^Post moderated. Please read The Rules and Using This Site.
Ziester said:I just popped in my copy of Alternative Redux and there's definitely still some narration.
Even if you like the narration you have to admit that some of it is repetitive and unnecessary.
Third Stage is impressive, but it keeps all of Lynch's more bizarre and unnecessary scenes like Paul magically making it rain the end.