- Messages
- 881
- Reaction score
- 1,232
- Trophy Points
- 118
Fell down another rabbit hole after a recent youtube essay about the storied production of Dick Tracy (1990), a movie that I have never felt a ton of love for due to the outrageous color scheme. (The makeup fx were always downright nuts to me as well).
I wanted to try a little experiment - how would a black and white version feel? Like the old original Dick Tracy movies, not the comic strip? So of course I snagged the Blu Ray.
Compare this original scene:
to this slightly trimmed B&W version with a little film grain?
Completely different feel, kinda Hard-boiled vibe, kinda Sin City IMO
This was interesting enough to keep going down the rabbit hole. But... wow. I had not watched this movie in SOOO long. Its amazing that this came out the year after the first Keaton Batman - in that respect is a complete ripoff, blasphemous in retrospect really. I can't believe I didn't notice back then it was THIS similar to the Batman.
But its amazing how I could actually appreciate everything in this movie without all the color - even the makeup isn't quite so bad. It seems like THE PERFECT movie that a Young Bruce Wayne would have watched. So many similarities to Batman, besides the soundtrack that due to Elfman sounds like it uses the same exact score as Batman, Big Boy seems like Joker and Penguin merged, and Dick Tracy seems like Batman if he were a cop. Elliot Ness similarities, sure, but this is a superhero before there were superheroes. Kid is basically Robin, its so weird how much this copies and tries to be a prequel. I don't think I noticed before with all the color and ridiculous makeup. But it also hit some pretty iconic "noir" beats too.
So as a break from some of the (hopeless) fanmixes I am struggling with, I worked on a quick little experiment. And my growing buzz while working on it may have affected this edit LOL. I started with the intent to remove excess shots of bad makeup, and the corny lines I remember. Big Boy should be darker and more menacing, less of a parody.
And that worked well for a while. Lots of dumb lines removed or edited for pacing. Songs trimmed when the narrative allows. But then, there were some actually funny moments. I think the Kid eating montage I think was the first one that caught me off guard. Then, while I was able to cut some of the initial corniness from Big Boy, he had a few jokes that landed that I couldn't remove. So Big Boy starts off more menacing, but leans into satire as the movie progresses. His "quotes" are still removed, but I let Pacino off the leash after a while.
Otherwise, I try to lean into the noir element, with Dick being edited to have a bit more confidence, less doubt, except when it comes to women. I initially tried to make this an adult movie, and remove the corny kids stuff. I go back and forth removing the part about the "Kid" getting a certificate and changing his name to Dick Tracy, but Dick Tracy seemed to need any character depth I could find. Not cutting quite as much as the "Trueheart Edition" by @revstevens (which I am sure is amazing in its own artistic POV! RESPECT.)
Anyways - I think there is a more timeless version in this old over-saturated turd (a turd that won Oscars, that is - With three Oscars, Dick Tracy is currently tied with Black Panther for having the most wins for a comic book movie.)
Previews available, requesting feedback!
Am I way off even attempting this?
Here is another sample of the new vibe.
New clip:
And the original:
Last edited: