I didn't realize at first that this thread had been started such a long time ago. I just saw the newest comments and didn't notice when the original posts were made!
Would people still pick the same edits as being the best, or would they go with different ones now? It's been over a year since the thread was started, and I'm sure there have been more prequel edits released since then.
Of course, all of the editors who put in such time and effort should be congratulated. But I need to expand my knowledge of prequel fan editing, and it can be a tad overwhelming going to the Database and seeing so many different prequel edits, most of which have really good ratings, so one doesn't seem to be significantly better than the other.
Off the top of my head, here's what I've seen so far (not counting parodies): the original Phantom Edit, the Phantom Re-Edit, Ep. II Super 8 Version, and L8's trilogy. There are probably other Ep. I edits I've seen, but I'll have to look them up later.
Which other edits should I see, particularly for Eps. II and III, to be a well-rounded prequel fan edit viewer?