- Messages
- 479
- Reaction score
- 2
- Trophy Points
- 21
So I've enjoyed some of the lord of the rings "By the book" edits. Now that there are a bunch of hobbit edits out, which is the best book matching edit?
Read BEFORE posting Trades & Request
Kal-El said:Kerr's book cuts are very great, although that's LOTR.
Neglify said:Check out "The Hobbit: The Tolkien Edit". A 3-in-1 edit based off the book as closest as he could get. It was never submitted here due to using bootlegged sources (he came out with the edit when BOTA was still in theaters). But it's a pretty damn good edit and very faithful to the book. You can find it on his blog, which you can find by googling easy enough.
TV's Frink said:Thread moved to Fanedit Comparisons.
Neglify said:Check out "The Hobbit: The Tolkien Edit". A 3-in-1 edit based off the book as closest as he could get. It was never submitted here due to using bootlegged sources (he came out with the edit when BOTA was still in theaters). But it's a pretty damn good edit and very faithful to the book. You can find it on his blog, which you can find by googling easy enough.
ranger's edit is probably the best edit of DOS, there is an unofficial purist edit of AUJ on the torrent network, you can search for ***torrent information removed by moderator***Kal-El said:Kerr's book cuts are very great, although that's LOTR. ranger613 his Into the Fire (purist) cut of The Desolation of Smaug was VERY enjoyable and is HIGHLY recommended!
Don't really have a preference as for the first film.
Kal-El said:hasmak I'm just trying to help out Ken, not looking for one myself.
hasmak said:ranger's edit is probably the best edit of DOS, there is an unofficial purist edit of AUJ on the torrent network, you can search for ***torrent information removed by moderator***
I don't know if the torrent is still alive, if it is dead and you are really keen, let me know and I'll try to upload it for you.
There is also the Biblical Cut by " lf-pegip " links available on Tumblr, search for "The Hobbit The Biblical Cut" or for the editor name.
As far as I know, no one has done an edit of BOTFA on its own (if you know of any please let me know) , but there are several 3 in 1 edits available