I thought it was OK but not great, maybe a 6 out of 10. This was a documentary about his death more than his life and it completely skipped over his post Siskel career and didn't have any comments from Richard Roeper which was odd. I would have liked some comments from Oprah about their relationship too but again it skipped over that. I think a documentary on just At The Movies would be great, they spent way to little time on the show that made him a star