Canon Editor
Well-known member
- Messages
- 1,730
- Reaction score
- 80
- Trophy Points
- 53
I do believe that when Disney and Lucasfilm will get to the point of wanting to reboot the Saga and so forth, they should think more thrice than twice.
Read BEFORE posting Trades & Request
DigModiFicaTion said:It would be interesting to see a live action troopers show, like IMPs or Troopers. Or a live action Rebels show. I just can't stand these terrible cgi shows. Star Wars needs more non lightsaber options.
TM2YC said:I've said it before... Disney will be making at least one SW movie a year, from now until our sun goes supernova, so yes, sooner or later they will remake the prequels, remake the OT and create a Lobot origins movie.
Canon Editor said:I do believe that when Disney and Lucasfilm will get to the point of wanting to reboot the Saga and so forth, they should think more thrice than twice.
Moe_Syzlak said:I don't know. Maybe someday, but not for a while I'd guess. There were three total stinkers in a row and the third is still the 30th most profitable movie of all time. Star Wars seems pretty immune. People will see them no matter what.
Zamros said:While I agree that I don't think the prequels should be remade (Extensive fanediting is fair game, ofc ), not sure I agree with this guy's line of thinking.
"People love X so it shouldn't be remade" could be applied to literally anything. The reason things are remade is precisely BECAUSE people love them. We've been adapting and re-writing works of literature, literally since the first stories were told.
Officially replacing what George Lucas created and intended in the timeline, I feel, would be very disrespectful. I mean how would you feel if something you've worked on and are proud of, is denied and replaced with a different version of what you did?
TM2YC said:If they are, then it's the best kept secret of all-time and governments should probably employ George Lucas as an international super spy.
Moe_Syzlak said:I disagree that the prequels can be salvaged by fan editing. I've watched more than I care to admit and I've yet to find anything that comes close to making them good movies. The reason there are so many is precisely because people keep trying to fix something that simply can't be fixed. If they were salvageable, someone would've salvaged them long ago.
Zamros said:Officially replacing what George Lucas created and intended in the timeline, I feel, would be very disrespectful. I mean how would you feel if something you've worked on and are proud of, is denied and replaced with a different version of what you did?
Oh. You mean like what George Lucas, himself, did?
TVs Frink said:"The Star Wars Prequels are Secretly Brilliant?"
I'm sorry but I can't possibly watch that.
TM2YC said:If they are, then it's the best kept secret of all-time and governments should probably employ George Lucas as an international super spy.
Moe_Syzlak said:Is that the stupid ring theory thing? I disagree that the prequels can be salvaged by fan editing. I've watched more than I care to admit and I've yet to find anything that comes close to making them good movies. The reason there are so many is precisely because people keep trying to fix something that simply can't be fixed. If they were salvageable, someone would've salvaged them long ago.
TM2YC said:Now if this guy could just do the entire film it'd be a fanediting dream source...
Moe_Syzlak said:Alright, I watched it. So basically the case he's making is that Anakin's turn was because of the Jedi and the hypocrisy of the Jedi code rather than to save Padme. First, if that's the case, he's just made an argument that Lucas is (not so secretly) a terrible storyteller. Because that doesn't come through at all. But even if it did, it's basically the equivalent of saying because some of the allied power leaders were a bit hypocritical, I'm going to side with the genocidal Nazis. And for what reason? Spite? If that's the intent is the PT is actually secretly much MUCH worse. (IMO)
Moe_Syzlak said:The video you posted calls Anakin's fear of loss of Padme "the straw that broke the camel's back" and "not the main reason" for Anakin's turn. If you're suggesting that everyone missed the fact that the Jedi order and code were flawed and Anakin's distrusted them, well I think you're wrong. I'm frankly tired of people trying to tell me I've missed some hidden brilliance here.
TVs Frink said:That's one reason why I don't watch video reviews or essays.