Well the quality of this one is pretty off the scales. I'm not really seeing the point of the narrative and it feels pretty fan servicey to have them fight, but this really was impressive stuff akin to the Darth Maul fan film. The only real negatives I see are the look of it, not sure if it's a lighting thing or a frame rate thing but it doesn't look like film, and the lightsaber battle was pretty scripted and unnatural looking. Fan films are really coming along.