MCP
Well-known member
- Messages
- 12,994
- Reaction score
- 483
- Trophy Points
- 168
Batman v Superman: No Justice:
Really a phenomenal edit, the type that you wouldn't even notice had you not seen the movie before. Transitions are professionally done both in the sound and shot selection. No story loopholes created by the editing, and brighter visuals than the original. I will say that as for the movie itself, its just good enough to be considered ok to decent and this is no fault of the editor as he only has the finished product to work with. Without the editing however, the original is a massive train-wreck in story telling and its amazing how much better it is when its cleaned up a bit. I think its safe to say the critics would not have been nearly as harsh on this film had it been released in this form.
P.S.
Would love to see Reese edit a short film (10-20 minutes) that would bridge the gap between his edit and Justice League. Perhaps, it begins with a cold intro that explains a leftover fragment of the kryptonian ship had a super weapon inside of it and then cuts right into the beginning of the battle with Doomsday, afterwards showing supermans funeral and Bruce's pledge to form the League or even the few scenes introducing Diana at the museum or something. I do agree with his decision to leave this out of his final product however, I'd be cool if he could find a way to bridge his edit with the rest of the DC movies.
https://ifdb.fanedit.org/batman-v-superman-no-justice/discussions/9342/
Really a phenomenal edit, the type that you wouldn't even notice had you not seen the movie before. Transitions are professionally done both in the sound and shot selection. No story loopholes created by the editing, and brighter visuals than the original. I will say that as for the movie itself, its just good enough to be considered ok to decent and this is no fault of the editor as he only has the finished product to work with. Without the editing however, the original is a massive train-wreck in story telling and its amazing how much better it is when its cleaned up a bit. I think its safe to say the critics would not have been nearly as harsh on this film had it been released in this form.
P.S.
Would love to see Reese edit a short film (10-20 minutes) that would bridge the gap between his edit and Justice League. Perhaps, it begins with a cold intro that explains a leftover fragment of the kryptonian ship had a super weapon inside of it and then cuts right into the beginning of the battle with Doomsday, afterwards showing supermans funeral and Bruce's pledge to form the League or even the few scenes introducing Diana at the museum or something. I do agree with his decision to leave this out of his final product however, I'd be cool if he could find a way to bridge his edit with the rest of the DC movies.
https://ifdb.fanedit.org/batman-v-superman-no-justice/discussions/9342/