MCP
Well-known member
- Messages
- 12,828
- Reaction score
- 442
- Trophy Points
- 168
Heavy Star Wars: Episode IV:
Kick-ass!
This was a joy to watch, completely new way of viewing the scenes, especially the action scenes which morph into montage music videos. Some sections worked spectacularly, such as the escape from Tatooine, everything around the Death Star, and the entire final battle. Most other sections were good too, but Comfortably Numb was disappointing because of the placement (way too early for such a dramatic song), and the R2D2 acid trip was weeiirddd.
One point off video quality for using lots of special edition shots, one point off visual editing for the occasionally excessive trippy effects, and two points off narrative because it was a bit choppy. I enjoyed many of the trims (and how they fit the music) but it would have been hard to understand for a first-time viewer.
Overall loved it! Can't watch to watch the rest of the series!!
https://ifdb.fanedit.org/heavy-star-wars-episode-iv/discussions/9246/
Kick-ass!
This was a joy to watch, completely new way of viewing the scenes, especially the action scenes which morph into montage music videos. Some sections worked spectacularly, such as the escape from Tatooine, everything around the Death Star, and the entire final battle. Most other sections were good too, but Comfortably Numb was disappointing because of the placement (way too early for such a dramatic song), and the R2D2 acid trip was weeiirddd.
One point off video quality for using lots of special edition shots, one point off visual editing for the occasionally excessive trippy effects, and two points off narrative because it was a bit choppy. I enjoyed many of the trims (and how they fit the music) but it would have been hard to understand for a first-time viewer.
Overall loved it! Can't watch to watch the rest of the series!!
https://ifdb.fanedit.org/heavy-star-wars-episode-iv/discussions/9246/