Vote for the August 2016 FEOTM

[lastb0isct]

PM the editor.  You should also read the rules.

Thank you!  I'll do that.

[Evil Dad]

re-(a)ward

"Award"

No, I meant Reward/Award

[Evil Dad]

... but like I said we did this a long time ago.

No, you said a while ago. This isn't necessarily a long time.

[addiesin]

re-(a)ward

"Award"

No, I meant Reward/Award

I see.

[ThrowgnCpr]

... but like I said we did this a long time ago.

No, you said a while ago. This isn't necessarily a long time.

Why are you arguing semantics? It's a moot point. I was pretty clear in that we didn't change it during this particular contest. 

I'm going to ask that everyone stop posting their opinions in this thread on how we organize the monthly polls. Have more to say? Then please check out the threads that Frink referenced here:

The final "Fanedit of the Month" contest was for April 2013.

https://forums.fanedit.org/showthread.php?tid=7824
(includes discussion of the voting process and bionicbob first suggesting the name change)

The first "Favorite Edit of the Month" contest was for May 2013.
https://forums.fanedit.org/showthread.php?tid=8010

Any discussion of the voting process not specific to this month's contest should go here:
https://forums.fanedit.org/showthread.php?tid=6818

Please keep discussion here focused on the edits and their comparable merits.

[Evil Dad]

... but like I said we did this a long time ago.

No, you said a while ago. This isn't necessarily a long time.

Why are you arguing semantics? It's a moot point. I was pretty clear in that we didn't change it during this particular contest. 

I'm going to ask that everyone stop posting their opinions in this thread on how we organize the monthly polls. Have more to say? Then please check out the threads that Frink referenced here:

The final "Fanedit of the Month" contest was for April 2013.

https://forums.fanedit.org/showthread.php?tid=7824
(includes discussion of the voting process and bionicbob first suggesting the name change)

The first "Favorite Edit of the Month" contest was for May 2013.
https://forums.fanedit.org/showthread.php?tid=8010

Any discussion of the voting process not specific to this month's contest should go here:
https://forums.fanedit.org/showthread.php?tid=6818

Please keep discussion here focused on the edits and their comparable merits.

I'm not trying to be argumentive, but I was under the impression that the name change just happened which triggered my response. Also because all the awarded edits are still called "Fanedit of the Month Winner" on the site.

[TVs Mountbatten-Windsor]

You have been asked to redirect this conversation to a more appropriate thread and you keep ignoring the request.  Knock it off.

This will be our last request to get back on-topic.  The next post that does not relate to THIS MONTH'S CONTEST will receive an infraction, and similar subsequent posts may result in a ban.

[Evil Dad]

Is this poll still open? If not can I assume J.R.R. Tolkien’s The Hobbit a Maple Films edit by eldusto84 is the winner?

[ThrowgnCpr]

We got started on it a couple days late, so it ran a couple days into October to allow for enough votes. It's closed now, and eldusto84 is indeed the winner.

[eldusto84]

Thank you to all those who voted for J.R.R. Tolkien's The Hobbit! I apologize for causing a bit of a kerfluffle during the voting process however. This was my first-ever fanedit so I'll use this as a learning experience for the next one.