If this is your first time here please read our FAQ and Rules pages. They have some useful information that will get us all off on the right foot. More details on our policies, especially our Own the Source rule are available here. If you do not understand any of these rules send a private message to one of our staff for further details.

STAR WARS: Rogue One
(07-25-2018, 12:48 AM)RobertWhite Wrote:
(06-03-2017, 11:03 AM)TomH1138 Wrote: I also loved the fact that this move didn't open with a typical crawl, https://www.stlcurioshoppe.com/v-tight-gel-review/ didn't do the customary wipes and  so forth, did do things we've never seen in a Star Wars movie such as flashbacks, etc.

I was also quite surprised to see flashbacks in the movie - never expected it. But I'm a die hard Star Wars fan and loved the movie.

same here Smile
Watched TM2YC's edit of this the other night, only the second time I've seen any version of the film. Now that on-screen Star Wars combat isn't as novel as it was back in 2016, thanks largely to The Mandalorian, and I was familiar with the story, the ragged nature of the script really stood out. Jyn goes from completely blowing off the struggle against the Empire to being a passionate, Hope!-boosting leader merely from watching her father's message, and it just doesn't work. (Also, the repeated use of "hope" was overdone.) The random "save the cat!" moment of Jyn saving the little girl in the firefight was, to quote Luke, A Cheap Move. What's more, though the Vader scene at the end is still awesome, I wish we didn't hear him speak (TM2YC left in one of his lines, which IMO is one line too many) - he would have been more imposing as a silent presence, and JEJ's voice is just too audibly aged.

In conclusion, then, while the Battle of Scarif is without doubt the finest action sequence of the new movies Rogue One is a pretty meh flick overall. Meaning that the reigning champion of Disney Star Wars movies is... (DigModiFicaTion's edit and re-grade of) Solo! Solo is a decent adventure that should have been a Disney+ series, allowing for several short adventures rather than one big one, and Rogue One should have spent much more time developing Jyn and Cassian, rather than making some character from the cartoons so central to the plot for no apparent reason. (Why does the designer of the Death Star just happen to be good buddies with one of the galaxy's most prominent/notorious rebels?) As for Cassian, while Diego Luna is awesome, I'm not sure how much room there is to develop his character in a Disney+ series. I'm afraid I'm a bit less intrigued by it now than I was before this re-watch.

Such, anyway, are my two cents. Smile
[+] 2 users Like Gaith's post
My two cents:  Rogue One is, despite maybe being a tad too long, a really good movie.
[+] 1 user Likes TVs Frink's post
(03-25-2020, 09:06 AM)TVs Frink Wrote: My two cents:  Rogue One is, despite maybe being a tad too long, a really good movie.

Concur. It’s a good movie made really good by Digmodification IMO.

Forum Jump:

Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)