If this is your first time here please read our FAQ and Rules pages. They have some useful information that will get us all off on the right foot. More details on our policies, especially our Own the Source rule are available here. If you do not understand any of these rules send a private message to one of our staff for further details.

January 2019 FEOTM - Every month we ask the community to vote on their Favorite Fanedit of the Month. To view the nominees and vote visit this thread.

Trouble Remuxing an MKV File with V_MS/VFW/FOURCC Codec (Superman Returns)
#1
I used MakeMKV on a Windows 10 machine to rip my Superman Returns Blu-ray. I am using Final Cut Pro on my Mac for editing. As such, my first step is to remux my MKV files to either MP4 or M4V. Most video files I rip using MakeMKV use the popular H.264 codec and are easy to remux. My Superman Returns files use the V_MS/VFW/FOURCC codec, and no matter what I try, I can't get the video remuxed. The audio remuxes fine, but the video won't. I tried using Subler and FFmpeg to remux the video (though I cannot guarantee that I was using FFmpeg correctly).

To possibly solve the problem on the other end, are there any settings in MakeMKV I can check that'd get it to rip the video using the H.264 codec instead? I doubt it, but worth checking.

Any assistance that can be provided would be greatly appreciated. Thanks so much!
Reply
#2
Can't you just remux the M2TS from the BRD directly?
Reply
#3
QuackAtomic Wrote:Can't you just remux the M2TS from the BRD directly?

I don't know. How would I go about doing this?
Reply
#4
I should also mention that this is the region-free international version of the Blu-ray. Not sure if that makes a difference, but maybe that's why this disc is different than others I've ripped.
Reply
#5
Have you tried TSMuxer? I've recently started using it and found it very easy to use for stuff like this.

Just drop the Blu-ray's *.M2TS file straight into it and you should get a list of the streams, then demux them as you wish and stick them into an MP4 or MKV. If you get stuck with that please post a screengrab of the stream list from TSMuxer, so we can all see what you are dealing with.
Reply
#6
Son of Suns Wrote:I don't know. How would I go about doing this?

I use MKVMerge, and it allows me to select the M2TS straight off the BRD rip. I copy the entire disc to my hard drive, then use MKVMerge to select the M2TS (found in the "STREAM" folder of the BRD). And it opens a selection screen of available streams. Just select the pieces you want for your new file, and press 'start muxing.' Works for me.

Now, if what you're saying is that none of those options are H264, or what have you, then I'm not sure.
Reply
#7
QuackAtomic Wrote:I use MKVMerge, and it allows me to select the M2TS straight off the BRD rip. I copy the entire disc to my hard drive, then use MKVMerge to select the M2TS (found in the "STREAM" folder of the BRD). And it opens a selection screen of available streams. Just select the pieces you want for your new file, and press 'start muxing.' Works for me.

Now, if what you're saying is that none of those options are H264, or what have you, then I'm not sure.

How do you copy the entire Blu-ray disc to your hard drive (as opposed to just copying files from it)? Is there a program you can use to do that?

I apologize for the beginner questions. I'm having some difficulty figuring this out, but I'm excited to get started once I do.
Reply
#8
TM2YC Wrote:Have you tried TSMuxer? I've recently started using it and found it very easy to use for stuff like this.

Just drop the Blu-ray's *.M2TS file straight into it and you should get a list of the streams, then demux them as you wish and stick them into an MP4 or MKV. If you get stuck with that please post a screengrab of the stream list from TSMuxer, so we can all see what you are dealing with.

I tried using TSMuxer to demux just the movie to start with (none of the special features yet). When I copied this with MakeMKV, the file ended up being 25 GB. Demuxing it with TSMuxer gave me two files - an MPV that's 4.5 GB and an AC3 that's 240 MB. Does that sound right to you? Shouldn't the files be practically the same size?

I'll upload a screenshot soon.
Reply
#9
Son of Suns Wrote:How do you copy the entire Blu-ray disc to your hard drive (as opposed to just copying files from it)? Is there a program you can use to do that?

I use Magic Blu-Ray Copy, which costs about about $50. There's lots of different freeware you can try too. Check out VideoHelp.com, they've got a lot of free tools for video editing and production. I haven't used any of the freeware rippers, but I hear Clown_BD is pretty good.
Reply
#10
QuackAtomic Wrote:I use MKVMerge, and it allows me to select the M2TS straight off the BRD rip. I copy the entire disc to my hard drive, then use MKVMerge to select the M2TS (found in the "STREAM" folder of the BRD). And it opens a selection screen of available streams. Just select the pieces you want for your new file, and press 'start muxing.' Works for me.

Now, if what you're saying is that none of those options are H264, or what have you, then I'm not sure.

Alright, so I used MKVMerge to take the MPV and AC3 files I had gotten by demuxing it with TSMuxer and put them back together as an MKV, then I used ShanaEncoder to remux that into an MP4. I then transferred that file over to my Mac (I rip on a Windows laptop because it's my only computer with a Blu-ray drive but I use Final Cut Pro on my Mac for editing). I double-checked the MP4 in VLC Media Player, and it played great. I then tried to import this file into Final Cut Pro. The audio worked great, but the video came through as nothing but green. I can't figure out why.

This has been such a frustrating process. I've never had this much difficulty with any other Blu-ray.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)