[MENTION=13347]Moe_Syzlak[/MENTION], I also just read that whole pointless thread. Seems the guy had an edit with a unanimously bad narrative, which is, barring nothing else, the single most important component of any work of fiction. Good looking effects and video are icing, but a good narratives the cake. I can't judge it because I didn't watch the edit, and it does seem to be an over reaction for him to leave that site completely.
He should certainly have been more political to keep the mods/admin happy. I myself was asked to remove an edit recently for technical (not narrative) reasons, so I tossed it, but learned a lesson from this --not releasing anything SD again and only working off blurays from now, to keep the technical folks happy while I get to go on making (hopefully) good narratives; not throw a tantrum and lose your audience (who are the most important folks on these sites). Worst thing was all the people who were giving him genuinely good feedback and encouragement throughout on how to improve the story, who he referred to as presumptuous and rude, before leaving. Not professional