Been meaning to check out Oppenheimer - but the 3 hour run time makes me think twice. Do you think it’s a movie you have to see in a movie theater ?
Firstly, I'll say that the editing is a miracle and the 3 hours doesn't exactly
fly by, but it really does keep you engaged for most of it. The sound mix is phenomenal and something I think you'd need to see in the theater unless you have an amazing home system. Visuals came off as just good in my cinema, but I reckon if there was an IMAX nearby it'd be a transcendent experience. TM2YC can speak to that.
I don't exactly when or why but something happened in the 10-years after that because I remember watching 2006's 'This Film Is Not Yet Rated' (a fantastic doc about the US censorship system) and thinking bloody hell, thank heavens we've got such a chilled, permissive and sensible ratings system in the UK (compared to what looked like the secretive, prudish and irrational US censors).
Well, the main thing that struck me about the UK system was the
criminalization of penalties for distributors. Like, going to
prison is just not even a tangential possibility for a US distributor. It's purely an artistic struggle, and the studio in theory always can take a gamble and just release a film without submitting to MPAA rating, or with whatever they've slapped on it.
Basic Instinct for instance, after trying to play along and making several cuts, released an "NC-17" version to the theaters and promoted it, ending up with tons of ticket sales and hype as a result. The appeal was such that the distributor decided to put an "R" version into wide release, where it became a smash hit rather than a little genre flick. The director's original cut was then released on home video, which had the stuff the censors (UK and US) typically really get their hackles up about: sexual gratification simultaneous with violence. There's a feature on the DVD that talks about the cuts frame-by-frame!
Watching
Empire of the Censors, the thing that struck me was that after the '50s, I kept waiting for the censorship to ease up...but nope, every couple of years there was some new film that the British populace seemed to get their knickers in a twist about, often leading to new legislation penalizing release of the (usually American) cuts of films! This was all the way up until the release of the doc in 1995! So my guess is that the internet is what really broke things open, making it practically impossible to contain these alternate cuts of films and prevent them from being seen in the UK.