Fanedit Forums
CBR List of 15 Fan Edits Better Than Original - Printable Version

+- Fanedit Forums (https://forums.fanedit.org)
+-- Forum: Fanedit.org Discussions (https://forums.fanedit.org/forumdisplay.php?fid=8)
+--- Forum: Front Page News (https://forums.fanedit.org/forumdisplay.php?fid=54)
+--- Thread: CBR List of 15 Fan Edits Better Than Original (/showthread.php?tid=15865)

Pages: 1 2


CBR List of 15 Fan Edits Better Than Original - bionicbob - 10-22-2017

Comic Book Resources posted a list of their 15 favourite fan edits.  Though oddly they do not go into great detail or mention the name of the fan editor or even our site.   But the majority of these fan edits originated on our site and were created by members of our community.

http://www.cbr.com/better-fan-movie-edits/

Big Grin


RE: CBR List of 15 Fan Edits Better Than Original - DigModiFicaTion - 10-22-2017

Wow that's pretty awesome Smile Thanks for sharing this bob!


RE: CBR List of 15 Fan Edits Better Than Original - TomH1138 - 10-23-2017

Nice article! Also a bit surprising that Adywan isn't mentioned, but still worth a read.


RE: CBR List of 15 Fan Edits Better Than Original - musiced921 - 10-23-2017

Great article!  To go in an opposite direction to TomH1138, I'm surprised that I was mentioned.  Wish the article included names of the editors.


RE: CBR List of 15 Fan Edits Better Than Original - TVs Frink - 10-23-2017

(10-23-2017, 10:15 AM)TomH1138 Wrote: Nice article! Also a bit surprising that Adywan isn't mentioned, but still worth a read.

They should have replaced Despecialized with Revisited.  Despecialized is not better than the original, it (for all intents and purposes) is the original.


RE: CBR List of 15 Fan Edits Better Than Original - beezo - 10-23-2017

Great article, likely written by someone who has never seen any of the fan edits they're talking about.


RE: CBR List of 15 Fan Edits Better Than Original - DigModiFicaTion - 10-23-2017

(10-23-2017, 01:11 PM)beezo Wrote: Great article, likely written by someone who has never seen any of the fan edits they're talking about.

What are you talking about? I've seen all of those....err I mean I'm sure the author has watched all of those. Wink kidding of course


RE: CBR List of 15 Fan Edits Better Than Original - TomH1138 - 10-23-2017

(10-23-2017, 12:16 PM)TVs Frink Wrote: They should have replaced Despecialized with Revisited.  Despecialized is not better than the original, it (for all intents and purposes) is the original.

Agreed! 

I wonder if the author realized that Despecialized and Revisited aren't the same thing. There seems to be a little confusion in the article, anyway. The author says Despecialized are Blu-ray quality, but I'm pretty sure they're DVD quality. (Someone correct me if I'm wrong.)

And as musiced921 mentioned, it would have been nice for the editors themselves to be acknowledged.

Still, it's a nice article that creates positive attention for the art form. Smile


RE: CBR List of 15 Fan Edits Better Than Original - TVs Frink - 10-23-2017

Sorry Tom but you're wrong - Despecialized is 720p.


CBR List of 15 Fan Edits Better Than Original - MCP - 10-23-2017

This is the discussion thread for CBR List of 15 Fan Edits Better Than Original. Post away!