- Messages
- 2,049
- Reaction score
- 948
- Trophy Points
- 128
You could replace the shotgun with a walkie talkie.
Vote now in wave 1 of the FEOTM Reboot!
This is absolutely what it was. To the characters in Eternals, Batman and Superman are known but fictional.I thought it was pretty clear they were being referred to as fictional characters that exist in the MCU just like they do in the real world.
Good luck with this! While I didn't think the film was "the worst Marvel movie" or as bad as some people have said, it does seem like a really hard fan-edit. For me, the problems start at the roots, with mis-casting and a bad story. You can cut the script and performances all you want, but it won't change those fundamentals. That said, I thought Captain Marvel was unsalvageable, but Tremault's edit proved me wrong!I'm browsing through songs to figure out what mood I'd like to emphasize, and I haven't got it yet. I'm of two minds:
- Perspective 1: The Eternals are tragic heroes. This is a Greek play more than a bright-colored comic-book story.
- Perspective 2: The Eternals are family. For all the flaws they perceive in each other, they have formed the bond of family over thousands of years. When push comes to shove, they realize their bond.
I can't create new scenes, so I can't change the perspective too drastically. This is about setting my direction for editing decisions. Which of these angles do you find more interesting and why?
I found it inoffensive, kind of weak gag but I was more put off by the childish ‘hiding behind the book so Phastos doesn’t see me’ part and the mention of Ikaris being superman just prior to that. I think the dialog is probably too important to the overall narrative to remove completely so it’s either leave it intact or consider replacement shots I imagine.In Phastos' home, Ikaris breaks a table. I don't like the scene because a) I find the Ikea joke not funny, and b) it is redundant to establish Ikaris' dick-ish character since this edit shows his betrayal of Ajak before they visit Phastos.
But... much of the dialog is helpful/needed to set up Phastos attitude going into the final battle.
Several shots with relevant dialog show the broken table. Cutting those is proving to be a problem, either:
- tbe dialog gets replacement shots of listeners in the room (placing the speaker off-screen), or
- I cut far more of the scene.
What do you think of the scene? Indifferent, like it, hate it?