That is truly fascinating! Honestly, I am hardly the person to ask because I'm going to be biased about my work. I would say judging on reviews, and by how many requested but didn't review, there is a chance my edit would give you a pleasant experience, but I want to guess there must be at least 25% of people who don't like what I did....
I have zero actual evidence to back that up, and any who didn't like... may just not like the movie full stop. I didn't exactly transform the entire movie structure, the structure is mostly intact, it's more about the nuance of the characters.
My intent was certainly purely focused on making Carol likeable by removing more offensive moments and allowing her to connect with the other characters.
I meddled with bits and pieces, but if it turns out you hate the structure and pacing of it, I didn't do anything to that. ^^;
edit: tried to be more on point.